The Role and Welfare of Cart Donkeys Used in Waste Management in Karachi, Pakistan.
Authors: Shah Syed Zahir Ali, Nawaz Zahid, Nawaz Sher, Carder Gemma, Ali Manuchahar, Soomro Naimatullah, Compston Polly C
Journal: Animals : an open access journal from MDPI
Summary
# Editorial Summary: Cart Donkeys in Pakistani Waste Management Donkey-powered waste collection represents a critical—yet largely undocumented—infrastructure in Karachi, with 89% of the 200 donkey owners surveyed deriving their primary income from this work, despite concerning evidence that children under 18 comprise 62% of the direct workforce. Using the Standardised Equine-Based Welfare Assessment Tool (SEBWAT) on 204 animals alongside interviews with owners, households, and key informants, researchers identified substantial welfare deficits: over half the donkeys (52.9%) presented with body condition score 2, whilst muzzle mutilation affected 78.4% and superficial knee lesions occurred in 66.7% of assessed animals. Households relying on donkey carts reported that waste collection would collapse without them, underscoring the socioeconomic dependence on these animals despite severe welfare compromises. For equine professionals engaged in international work or advisory roles in South Asian contexts, these findings highlight the tension between livelihood necessity and animal welfare, suggesting that interventions must address both donkey husbandry standards and the structural barriers preventing owners from improving conditions without economic hardship. The prevalence of specific injuries—particularly muzzle damage and knee lesions—points to tractable welfare improvements through farriery consultation, tack modification, and owner education, though systemic change requires recognition of waste management's reliance on equine labour.
Read the full abstract on PubMed
Practical Takeaways
- •Working equine professionals in developing contexts should recognize that donkey-owning communities provide essential waste management services while their animals experience significant welfare concerns requiring intervention
- •Muzzle mutilation and superficial knee lesions are endemic in this population, suggesting need for targeted welfare education and affordable preventive interventions for cart donkey owners
- •Policy and development initiatives should acknowledge the economic necessity of donkey carts for marginalized communities while implementing evidence-based welfare improvements and alternative livelihood support
Key Findings
- •Waste collection was the primary income source for 89% of donkey cart owners in Karachi
- •52.9% of assessed donkeys had a body condition score of 2, indicating poor nutritional status
- •Muzzle mutilation was extremely prevalent at 78.4% and superficial knee lesions affected 66.7% of donkeys
- •Donkey carts play a critical role in waste management infrastructure, with customers reporting significant garbage buildup would occur without them