Conservative management of 17 horses with nonarticular fractures of the tibial tuberosity.

Authors: Arnold C E, Schaer T P, Baird D L, Martin B B

Journal: Equine veterinary journal

DOI: 10.2746/042516403776114261 PubMed: 12638799Log in to save

Summary

# Editorial Summary: Conservative Management of Tibial Tuberosity Fractures Tibial tuberosity fractures represent the second most common stifle injury in event horses, yet evidence supporting conservative (non-surgical) treatment protocols remains sparse. Arnold and colleagues reviewed 17 horses treated conservatively over a 15-year period, examining how fracture characteristics, concurrent soft tissue injury, and initial lameness severity influenced long-term athletic soundness. Among 15 horses completing the rehabilitation period (11–154 months follow-up), 12 (80%) successfully returned to their pre-injury competition level, with concurrent soft tissue damage emerging as the only statistically significant predictor of poor outcome—horses with associated ligamentous or capsular injury failed to return to prior athletic function. All other variables including fracture displacement, comminution, and degree of initial lameness showed no correlation with prognosis. These findings suggest that nonarticular tibial tuberosity fractures are candidates for conservative management in athletic horses, provided the injury remains uncomplicated by soft tissue involvement, which should guide clinical decision-making and owner counselling regarding rehabilitation timescales and realistic return-to-competition expectations.

Read the full abstract on PubMed

Practical Takeaways

•Conservative management of nonarticular tibial tuberosity fractures offers good prognosis for return to sport (80% success rate), making it a reasonable first-line approach before considering surgery
•Careful assessment for concurrent soft tissue damage to the stifle is critical at initial examination, as this is the primary factor determining athletic outcome
•Fracture fragment size and degree of displacement should not discourage conservative management, as these factors did not predict poor outcomes in this cohort

Key Findings

•80% (12/15) of horses with nonarticular tibial tuberosity fractures managed conservatively returned to athletic use at their previous level
•Concurrent soft tissue damage at time of initial injury was statistically significant in preventing return to competition
•All other variables including fracture size, degree of displacement, and comminution had no effect on outcome
•Conservative management is a viable treatment option for nonarticular tibial tuberosity fractures in athletic horses

Conditions Studied

nonarticular fractures of the tibial tuberositystifle traumasoft tissue damage to stifle supporting structures

Related References

Conservative versus surgical treatment of 21 sports horses with osseous trauma in the proximal phalangeal sagittal groove diagnosed by low-field MRI.

Lipreri Giulia, Bladon Bruce M, Giorio Maria Elisabetta, Singer Ellen R(2018)Veterinary surgery : VS

Fracture of the medial intercondylar eminence of the tibia in horses treated by arthroscopic fragment removal (21 horses).

Rubio-Martínez L M, Redding W R, Bladon B, Wilderjans H, Payne R J, Tessier C, Geffroy O, Parker R, Bell C, Collingwood F A(2018)Equine veterinary journal

Diagnosis, management, and outcome in 19 horses with deltoid tuberosity fractures.

Fiske-Jackson Andrew R, Crawford Andrew L, Archer R Michael, Bolt David M, Smith Roger K(2010)Veterinary surgery : VS

Osteoarthritis of the talocalcaneal joint in 18 horses.

Smith R K W, Dyson S J, Schramme M C, Head M J, Payne R J, Platt D, Walmsley J(2005)Equine veterinary journal

Modified Thomas splint-cast combination for the management of limb fractures in small equids.

Ladefoged Søren, Grulke Sigrid, Busoni Valeria, Serteyn Didier, Salciccia Alexandra, Verwilghen Denis(2017)Veterinary surgery : VS