What Is a Working Equid? Analysis of Current Terminology and a Suggested Definition.
Authors: Raw Zoe, Collins Joseph A, Burden Faith A
Journal: Animals : an open access journal from MDPI
Summary
# Editorial Summary: Defining "Working Equid" — Why Terminology Matters for Welfare Standards Globally The term "working equid" lacks a universally agreed definition in veterinary and equine literature, despite these animals playing a vital role in livelihoods across low- and middle-income countries; Raw, Collins and Burden examined how different terminology is used across 193 countries, finding significant associations between the search terms used and a country's World Bank income classification. Their literature review revealed that most equine work-related terminology (such as "pack equid," "beast of burden," and "draught animal") appeared predominantly in papers from high-income countries, whereas "working equid" and "draft equid" were notably more frequent in lower-income countries, often described within contexts of low-resource and marginalised communities. The authors propose adopting a standardised definition: "any equid engaged in physical labour that provides a significant or direct contribution to the economic livelihood, sustenance or support of the owner/user's family, typically within a low resource setting." This lack of linguistic consistency has real consequences—it hampers the development of equitable welfare policies, complicates resource allocation for animal health programmes, and prevents meaningful comparison of equid populations and their management across regions. For equine professionals working internationally or advising on welfare standards, adopting this unified terminology provides a framework for clearer communication and more effective advocacy for animals whose contribution to human survival and economic security remains fundamentally underrepresented in high-income country research.
Read the full abstract on PubMed
Practical Takeaways
- •Adopt the standardized term 'working equid' in professional communications to improve clarity and consistency across global contexts and income settings.
- •Recognize that working equids in lower-income countries are often integral to family livelihoods and require welfare approaches adapted to resource-limited environments rather than high-income country standards.
- •Advocate for policy and welfare standards development that bridges linguistic and cultural gaps, ensuring equitable treatment of working equids globally regardless of economic setting.
Key Findings
- •Search terminology for working equids is significantly associated with World Bank country income classification, with higher-income countries dominating most search terms.
- •The terms 'working equid' and 'draft equid' returned significantly more papers from lower-income countries than higher-income countries, though higher-income country papers focused on low-resource and marginalized communities.
- •A proposed definition of 'working equid' is: any equid engaged in physical labour providing significant or direct contribution to economic livelihood, sustenance or support within a low-resource setting.
- •Lack of universally accepted terminology for working equids creates challenges in policy formulation, resource allocation, and welfare standards development, particularly in lower-middle and low-income countries.