The sacroiliac joints: evaluation using nuclear scintigraphy. Part 2: Lame horses.

Authors: Dyson S, Murray R, Branch M, Harding E

Journal: Equine veterinary journal

DOI: 10.2746/042516403776148282 PubMed: 12755424Log in to save

Summary

# Editorial Summary: Sacroiliac Joint Evaluation Using Nuclear Scintigraphy in Lame Horses Diagnosing sacroiliac joint disease remains a clinical challenge, as clinical signs alone often prove unreliable; this study investigated whether quantitative analysis of radiopharmaceutical uptake patterns could differentiate SI joint pathology from other causes of lameness. Scintigraphic images from 234 lame horses (unrelated to SI disease), 40 normal working horses and 41 horses with suspected SI joint disease were analysed using ratio comparisons between the fifth lumbar vertebra and various sacral/SI structures, with particular attention to left-right symmetry. Horses with lameness from non-SI sources showed significantly greater asymmetry in tuber sacrale uptake compared with normal horses, and those with right hindlimb lameness exhibited disproportionately elevated right SI joint ratios—findings that could confound diagnosis. Marked left-right asymmetry on quantitative or profile analysis proved most useful for distinguishing SI joint disease from other causes, particularly when combined with supportive clinical signs; however, considerable overlap exists between groups, meaning scintigraphy cannot reliably diagnose SI disease in isolation. For practitioners, this work underscores that nuclear scintigraphy serves best as a complementary diagnostic tool within a broader clinical framework rather than as a standalone confirmatory test, and abnormal pelvic uptake patterns warrant cautious interpretation alongside lameness location, palpation findings and response to diagnostic analgesia.

Read the full abstract on PubMed

Practical Takeaways

•Nuclear scintigraphy can support clinical diagnosis of sacroiliac joint disease but should never be used in isolation; always correlate imaging findings with clinical signs and other diagnostic tests
•Asymmetrical radiopharmaceutical uptake and abnormal L5-to-SI joint ratios are suggestive of SI joint involvement, particularly when marked left-right differences are present
•Remember that lameness from other causes can produce similar scintigraphic findings, so SI joint disease diagnosis requires a multi-modal approach combining imaging, palpation, and response to diagnostic anesthesia

Key Findings

•Lame horses (Group I, n=234) showed greater asymmetry of radiopharmaceutical uptake in tubera sacrale compared to normal horses (Group N, n=40)
•Horses with right hindlimb lameness had significantly larger RSI/LSI ratios compared to normal horses
•Horses with presumed sacroiliac joint disease (Group II, n=41) had greater L5/LTS, L5/RTS and L5/RSI ratios compared to normal horses
•Marked left-right asymmetry detected by quantitative or profile analysis was helpful in discriminating SI joint disease from other causes of lameness, but overlap exists between groups

Conditions Studied

sacroiliac joint diseaselamenesshindlimb lameness

Related References

The sacroiliac joints: evaluation using nuclear scintigraphy. Part 1: The normal horse.

Dyson S, Murray R, Branch M, Whitton C, Donovan T, Harding E(2003)Equine veterinary journal

Pain associated with the sacroiliac joint region: a clinical study of 74 horses.

Dyson S, Murray R(2003)Equine veterinary journal

Review of the clinical diagnosis of sacroiliac dysfunction in horses - Challenges and limitations.

Walter L J, Stack J D, Winderickx K, Davies H M S, Simon O, Franklin S H(2024)Veterinary journal (London, England : 1997)

Ultrasonographic examination of the equine sacroiliac region.

Kersten A A M, Edinger J(2004)Equine veterinary journal

Close, impinging and overriding spinous processes in the thoracolumbar spine: the relationship between radiological and scintigraphic findings and clinical signs.

Zimmerman M, Dyson S, Murray R(2012)Equine veterinary journal