Competing interests at the heart of equine sports medicine ethics: A scoping review and thematic analysis.
Authors: Allen Kate, Anderson Lynley, King Mike, Mullan Siobhan
Journal: Equine veterinary journal
Summary
# Editorial Summary: Equine Sports Medicine Ethics — A Research Landscape Increasing public scrutiny of equine athletics has exposed a significant gap in veterinary guidance: whilst sports medicine ethics is well-established in human medicine, equine veterinary practice lacks comparable frameworks for navigating competing professional demands. Allen and colleagues conducted a scoping review of English-language literature published between 2000 and 2022, examining 41 papers (35 from veterinary sources) to identify the primary ethical tensions facing veterinary surgeons treating performance horses. Five key themes emerged—conflicting stakeholder interests, regulatory oversight, optimal care provision, client confidentiality, and professional social licence—with medication use in performance horses cited most frequently as a specific ethical flashpoint. The authors acknowledge their review mapped concerns rather than critically analysing the arguments themselves, yet their findings underscore an urgent professional need: veterinary governing bodies and sporting organisations must collaborate to establish clearer ethical boundaries that distinguish between permissible, optimal, excessive and impermissible practices in equine sports medicine. For equine professionals, this work represents a starting point for conversations within your own discipline about where professional duty ends and competing commercial or competitive interests begin.
Read the full abstract on PubMed
Practical Takeaways
- •Veterinary surgeons in equine sports medicine should be aware of multiple competing interests (horse welfare vs. owner/sport demands) and seek guidance on navigating ethical conflicts in practice
- •Clarification is needed from governing bodies and the veterinary profession on what constitutes ethical, optimal, excessive, permissible and impermissible veterinary practices in equine sports
- •Professional conduct frameworks and ethical decision-making processes should be established to support individual practitioners in maintaining high standards while managing stakeholder pressures
Key Findings
- •41 papers/articles identified addressing equine sports medicine ethics, with 35 from veterinary sources
- •Five major ethical themes emerged: competing stakeholder interests, governing bodies and regulations, optimal veterinary care provision, confidentiality, and professional social licence
- •Medication use in performance horses was the most commonly mentioned specific ethical concern across the literature
- •Limited application of established sports medicine ethics discipline (from human medicine) to equine veterinary practice identified as a gap